@Crimsonorblue22
The NCAA approves waivers but the school must appeal for one when the kid signs. And they were widely inconsistent (Shocking) in awarding them. A lot would apply for the waiver to be closer to home or a sick family member but some were trying to take advantage of the instant ability to play instead of sitting. The NCAA finally caught wind of that and put a end to it.
I honestly don't agree that kids should have to sit for anything but I understand it prevents flat out free agency so the year is a deterrent to that. It also gives kids the chance to academically get things in order when they transfer as I'm sure schools have different requirements for accepting credits.
One last thing, Schools do have the right to restrict kids from where they want to go with waivers unless the player makes it a media circus that eventually gets overturned. Case in point was Jared Uthoff who red-shirted at Wisconsin, he wanted out, Bo Ryan gave him basically a no transfer list to anyone until the media got hold of it. He actually ended up at Iowa in the same conference which is very rare to happen. This was after Wisconsin and Bo finally gave into the media pressure of the situation.
Hamilton of UCLA had to sit a year and lose a year of eligibility because Tim Floyd was convinced them and USC were poaching him to stay out west. He eventually transfered anyway but lost his Freshman year basically they wouldn't release his letter of intent.
Appalachian St forced DG to go to prep school because they were so vigilant about not releasing him. Seemed to work out for us in the end.
Who knows what would have happened with Frank had Towson not released him..