Coaching choices for KU:
Jay Wright-- Cant recruit a quality bigman, but looks George-Clooney-good in a suit. Just the guy if you have a collection of well-heeled, high-dollar female donors potentially in your alumni base, maybe? And he just beat Bill Self...
John Calipari-- (just included for chuckles...). Could he duplicate the recruiting at KU that he did at Memphis and Kentucky?
Mark Turgeon--(just included because many KU posters have a habit of bringing this name up, every year since his WSU team made the sweet16 once-upon-time). Really, what has he done? Surprisingly, his Maryland recruiting class is like Top5 this coming season. Let's see what he does with it. Overall, I'm not a fan of Roy ball. And Billy Self routinely beat the hell out of Mark's aTm teams nightly. Turgeon's aTm was the ugliest ball in the BigXII.
Billy Gillispie-- Yes, back from the blacklist...and yes, I'm just kidding. I hope he conquers his demons, but I think he's done coaching. Maybe like race car drivers...that window of peak productivity has passed Gillispie by. He cannot be the same guy he was at aTm. Should have never went to Kentucky.
Thad Matta--Quietly go see his W-L % in his 10yrs at OhioSt...its better than Roy's, and 2nd only to Bill Self. Only issue is twofold: He cannot beat Bill Self. He cannot win the big one. Decent recruiter.
Tom Crean-- His greatest player was Dwayne Wade. Enough said. Still have doubts that he isnt be the guy? Nope. See Indiana this season: cant see them, well go look over the edge of the cliff. That sort of pendulum does not happen to Bill Self. Was Indiana in the top25? Where's their "reload"?
Billy Donovan--Interesting idea. 2 NC winner...with same set of guys. Hasnt made a Final4 since then, has he? This year's flameout was worse than Self's, as we knew without Embiid we only had half a chance (too many flaws), but see, Florida cannot say that...they were a solid team, 26win streak, solid guardplay...and blew it in the E8.
Sean Miller--Who's better: Archie or Sean? Why didnt AZ make the Final 4? When was the last time AZ made a FinaLute Four? (hint) This isnt your daddy's Arizona...its worse. Sean Miller coaching example: See his best recruit's FT%, which was an absolute disgrace to Gordon's team, coaches past & present, and to the game of basketball. Even Collison and Langford can laugh at how bad Gordon's FTs were (47%). OK, that wasnt funny. Maybe Calipari can laugh, since that's a top5 recruit he didnt have to try to teach FT-shooting to...lol!
Jerrod Haase--Another KU kid. Well, he played tough. But he is a Roy disciple. Too little data. Must watch UAB's trajectory...
Shaka Smart--Surprised myself with this choice...He could be a savvy hire, able to recruit better with a royalty school's name...but if he hasnt done much lately, then his one-hit-wonder season with Skeen & Rodriguez makes you wonder how good his system really is. His VCU team got blown to bits in the 2013 Tourney with a 25pt loss...Is he starting to look more like Ben Jacobson at UNI? (one-hit wonder. Where is Jacobsen now? Oh, yeah, back to anonymouus in the brutal MVC...).
Danny Manning-- Nothing but questions. Yes, he got Tulsa back to the Tourney. But that's his one achievement. Watch Wake Forrest closely. Apparently he runs Self's system. And he spent 8+ yrs learning it from the master. And he should be able to recruit bigs to shine in it...Why doesnt Evan go play for his dad? What does Evan know...?
Gregg Marshall--Tough, team style of play. Defensive intensity. Recruiting is difficult to WichitaState, but he's had a formidable no-name team the past 2 seasons. Almost definitely underachieved this season, but welcome to life in the BigDance, Gregg. Could he recruit to KU? This would be the final straw for all the recent Shocker fans who've come out of the woodwork the last 2yrs...is if their coach leaves for KU! He did, after all, turn down UCLA (wisely), mostly because the money offered really didnt offset the cost of living in LA. So what would he have done if some school proposed an even better offer? Shocker Nation is on borrowed time, folks. Not saying Marshall is the best guy for KU, but an intruiguing pick in the up-and-comer crowd. Better than Shaka?
Brad Stevens--this is an intruiging choice, brought up several times by posters in our life-after-Self scenarios. Fact is, his recruiting is absolutely suspect. His rise was meteoric, but without anything except the 2 F4 runs, much like Donovan's back2back runs. But at least Billy Donovan can recruit better than Brad Stevens. Stevens may be a decent coach...but fact is he hasnt shown recruiting, and even his experienced squads got beat in the big game. Twice. Not a Brad Stevens fan, because I dont see repetetive, reproducible excellence with several sets of different players.
Lon Kruger--Sheahon Zenger brings it full circle, KSU AD hires KSU Men's basketball guy to coach KU. Fundamentals coach. Fair recruiter. Program builder. Ok, I'm only joking here...
Compared to...Bill Self-- A fundamentals guy. A proven A-rated recruiter. Repeatedly has gotten deep Tournament runs with several sets of players at 3 different schools (Tulsa, Illinois, KU). He just learned some things about his system and its limits being exposed by frosh and inexperienced execution. Self is a stubborn guy...but we shall see what this last year has done for his approach and preparation. Especially Tournament prep. He will always get armchair-QB'd by his fan base, as any coach at KU surely will. To this day, 10+ yrs later, many Illini remain utterly disgusted with KU for stealing their coach...and Cliff Alexander just put some more salt in that old wound. Why do the Illini still miss Bill Self? Havent they seen our killerB results, the early exits, Self getting slapped around by Izzo 3 times straight? Why all this angst over Bill Self?