@drgnslayr
You are on the right track here, though I would go much farther.
Like you I would say Lillard is at most a young star that has some potential to become a superstar.
Like you I would say that Lillard is only "called" a superstar largely because of off court stuff.
But then I would go further. I would make clear that superstar and star are anachronistic, 20th Century words referring to performance on the floor.
I would add that superstar in the present refers largely to off court stuff.
Then I would add that in the Age of Hypertelia, i.e., in the age in which the simulation model of a superstar (the hype generated off-court) has eclipsed the reality of the superstar's performance on-court, Damien Lillard is a simulated superstar.
I would point out that adidas desperately needs a simulated superstar, because Rose, once considered a 20th Century superstar throwback, and Howard, always a simulated superstar, have gone bust, leaving adidas without a superstar, or a simulated superstar to schlep shoes and outfits.
I would also point out that the recession in Europe and reputed changes in the stock ownership structure of adidas might put additional pressure on management to have a superstar, or simulated superstar, ASAP.
Lacking a handy 20th Century-style superstar, adidas management appears to have to spend the bones to generate a simulated superstar, because it is the minority duopolist in a highly asymmetric shoeco duopoly, and could find itself marginalized without at least a simulated superstar, until it can find a real one.
Compare what Damien Lillard's production on the floor now to real ones like Bill Russell, Wilt Chamberlain, Oscar Robertson, Julius Erving, Larry Bird, Magic Johnson, Michael Jordan, Shaq, Lebron, etc. These were superstars under the old on-floor, performance based criterion. I just don't see much comparison.
But we reputedly live in the hyperteliac age, when the simulation of reality has eclipsed reality.
Fine. I am willing to junk superstar and star entirely.
Let's coin a new hyperteliac word for Damien Lillard's current status.
How about "hyperstar"?
It seems less loaded and denigrating than "simulated superstar."
Damien Lillard is a hyperstar.
Who the flip cares if he ever becomes a 20th Century Anachronism "superstar"?
Power to the simulation!
And Andrew Wiggins is on the cusp of hyperstardom, IF he finds a marketing coach and a shoeco committed to hyperstar product endorsers.
What the hell! Maybe the game has just moved off the floor.
Maybe we need to start painting some name on the ribbon of space between the floor and the seating.
The name should be some master of simulation.
How about Jean Baudrillard Court?
Nah, he didn't go to KU.
Hey, in the age of simulation, let's just say he did.
Let the Midnight Special, shine its ever lovin' simulation on you!!
Rock Chalk!