John Calipari may not be the most-liked coach in college basketball. But you have to give him credit for trying new things.
His platoon system, to some degree, appears to be working. It may not put his best team on the floor to win for the majority of minutes, but it establishes a message to future recruits; Kentucky will be playing 10 players in key minutes. The system seems to work because none of the players seem to mind only getting to play half a game each. They seem to have bought in to the idea that all of their McD's deserve minutes, so they are willing to share.
Kansas does not have the overall depth that Kentucky has. But Kansas has more guards than minutes, so Bill Self will have to figure out what to do with his perimeter. In past years, Self had a cut off line on his roster. Players were either "in the minutes" or "out." It doesn't appear to be a system that works this year. The numbers just don't add up, and it seems unlikely that Self can just bench a highly-sought recruit for the entire year. That would definitely tarnish his future recruiting efforts because future recruits would see Kansas as a risky proposition for playing time.
It seems Kansas does have a problem similar to Kentucky, though only on the perimeter.
This should be a good problem to have. We've seen Kansas squander depth before by not giving gifted players enough minutes during the year, and then needing that depth in March but not having it because those players collected too much rust over the past months to 'knock it off" during tournament time.
Will Bill use a platoon system for his perimeter players?
Or will Bill issue playing time based on recent practice efforts?
Or will Bill simply bench some of his talent, and hope he doesn't pay an ultimate price down the road?
Being an American, through-and-through, I value the concept of competition. Competition forces guys to step up and produce. Produce or sit. But watching Kentucky's "socialized platoon system" has challenged my views. It seems like Calipari has convinced his players to "buy in" to his platoon system. In doing so, his players seem to be united even closer as a team. It still doesn't mean guys aren't competing, including for extra minutes, but it has largely removed a lot of the pressure of playing in a system that is "all or nothing." The system based on pure competition can actually divide players and create team issues. We just experienced a taste of that when we lost Kansas basketball diehard, Conner Frankamp. And Conner would have earned some key minutes this year.
Using Kentucky as the experiment, it seems that players like to feel a certain level of consistency. They want to know they will be a part of every game, a key part, and they are okay if their minutes shift a few plus or minus depending on their recent efforts in practice. The pressure has been reduced, so the focus is basketball, with a looser feel, but still very competitive.
These ideas are still new. We will all see how Kentucky's season progresses with the platoon system. Rest assured, for the most part, Calipari will keep this system all year. He has made the commitment to his players, and they have embraced it... so far!
Kansas can not afford to lose another player to transfer, especially coming from a highly-touted player. That is not the message we need to send to recruits considering Kansas. This would quickly send us back to lower recruits, back when our recruiting pitch involved words about how tough it was to get into the starting lineup at Kansas.