@JayHawkFanToo
I'd absolutely agree. But there are many around college basketball that question whether Indiana still belongs the game's elite. Their last Final Four appearance was in 2002. Their last title was in 1987. To put that in perspective, most of the guys that will be freshmen weren't even in school the last time Indiana was on the big stage. That matters.
No, Butler didn't leap to the forefront after going to consecutive title games. But look at a program like Florida. They weren't really a school with any kind of success 20 years ago, but now they can recruit on the same level as KU, because they have the two titles and multiple Final Fours over the last 15 years.
National prominence matters because we as KU have to recruit nationally. Kansas, Missouri, Iowa, and Oklahoma just don't produce enough high major talent for us to rely on being dominant only in conference. In Texas, we have to compete with the entire country for recruits. We have no geographic advantage to offer recruits.
Going back to Indiana, look at how many of the top recruits in Indiana are going out of state to Ohio State, Louisville, Kentucky and others. Historically, Indiana has more reach than both OSU and Louisville, but that doesn't matter to an 18 year old because, again, they probably don't remember the last time Indiana was in the Final Four. If a power program wants to maintain its national prominence, the had better be in the Final Four at least once every 5-7 years, and win a title at least once every 15 or so years, otherwise they will eventually get to a recruiting class that won't remember the last time they were on the national stage.
The kids in the Class of 2014 remember Mario's shot. They were 12 or 13 when that happened. They definitely remember Anthony Davis and MKG winning it all. They probably remember Florida going back to back. They probably don't know who Sean May is. They definitely don't know who Juan Dixon is.
I remember growing up, the first three really great college teams I remember were Duke, Arkansas and Michigan. I have no recollection of Glen Rice's Michigan teams, but I do remember the Fab 5. I remember Laettner and Hurley. I remember those really good 40 Minutes of Hell Arkansas teams. And I grew up in Kansas. Around a KU team that went to the Final Four in '88, '91 and '93. But I was too young to remember their title in '88. I only barely remember the 1991 season and going back to the title game. Duke sticks out because they went back to back, and while I have only vague memories of 1991, I remember 1992 very clearly. Michigan sticks out because they were in back to back title games. Arkansas was too, winning one and losing one. But notice something crazy about that list - one of the great teams I remember never won a conference title. I couldn't tell you who the Big 10 champs were either of those years, honestly. But I remember Michigan because they went to the Final Four.
It's easy as a fan to see things and feel like they should put us in the spotlight because we understand the significance. But honestly, if you're a 10 year old on the east coast right now, was KU really on your radar this year? UCLA? Indiana? If you're out west, have you paid any attention to North Carolina? Ohio State? Duke? Syracuse? That's three decades worth of national titles between those 7 schools. And yet, most of the kids in the Class of 2022 probably won't remember anything about their season this year.