Interesting thread... great job Ralster!
I think Izzo has no OADs because he is still pitching recruits what Self used to pitch when he wasn't getting any OADs... "you come to Kansas, you'll have to fight for PT. Nothing is a gimme. You first have to learn our system...."
I really think highly of Izzo. In the "teaching toughness" area, he's tops in the country. Even Huggy could stand to take notes from Izzo.
I think it's a mixed bag with OADs. Unless the player is a super freak... like JoJo, Wigs or the Unibrow, these kids need to stay in school for at least 2 years. Kelly, for example, isn't ready for the league and he hasn't even contributed enough to Kansas. We aren't coming out ahead with these kids going OAD. Maybe Wigs and JoJo were worth it because they will bring more attention to Kansas in the future. I do give them credit for helping us secure #10 in a complete rebuild year.
Calipari has it going on right this year. He has a team FULL of OADs but half or more have returned for year 2. Had all that talent crop left and he was stuck in a re-do year, Kentucky wouldn't be a contender for a NC... not this year.
I just think we need to find quality top recruits that want to stay more than one year in college... so we actually get a dividend out of them. Self is still building his own resume with OADs... so he is still stuck in the mode of how fast can he get them ready for draft day and positioned high in the draft. He is playing the old "revolving door" game. Once he gets this to the point Calipari has taken Kentucky, then he can loosely advice some of his OAD players to stay an extra year. Calipari orchestrated this year to happen. He sold most of his guys to stay.
I've been amazed with the media. They have been responsible for sending guys (like Kelly) out the door too quickly. When B12 regular season started and Kelly finally started showing some promise, the first words out of media were.. "be prepared Kansas fans... you only have a few more games left with Kelly because he is gone!" Seriously?! I know that plays in these kids' heads. It's sickening. The kid only scored 333 pts as a Jayhawk but he's ready for the pros? What kind of return did we make on him?
The game still has to be played. Kentucky is no shoe-in this year. I can even see the possibility that they may not make the FF. If they don't win it all, those guys will be laughed at from here to the moon and labeled "underachievers!" To be honest... all those guys except the twins and Cauley-Stein are underachievers. To have that much talent and be satisfied in a system where they only got half game PTs. None of those guys are showing they have a bit of alpha dog. Any of those guys could play anywhere else and be counted on for production and playing 35 mpg. The twins and CS are a different story. They weren't high draft material last year, and they have worked extremely hard in the off season to lift their games. They have improved (but still vulnerable). Pretty impressive to see their character to stick it out and work hard and Kentucky is now cashing in on signing them.
And what about basketball IQ? Wow... it really does matter who you recruit. Okafor and Alexander were considered neck-and-neck last year. Anyone think that today? Alexander's only offense was the stuff. Where would we be now if we had signed Okafor instead of Alexander? I'm guessing we would still be playing and a likely FF team!
I agree with @DCHawker ... Self's FF Runner-up was the corner for him. Proof that OADs can win titles. But come on... Davis was a super freak! And now look at him! He's killing it in the league.
Investment in the super luxury player suites is proof of the direction we are going in... O A D territory!