@HighEliteMajor
Thanks for the comments. Could we have reached the final four, sure. We did it in 2012. But should we have reached the final four, certainly not. We were not one of the best teams in the nation this year, and certainly not with Cliff (assuming Cliff would have peaked at just the right time which is a generous assumption).
The Final Four is indeed a crap shoot, depending upon match ups, luck, getting hot at the right time, injuries, eligibility issues, one guy making a miracle play at just the right time, etc.
My point is your postings often seem to criticize the coach b/c he does not make it to every final four, and it is somehow his fault b/c he certainly has the talent, and therefore he is doing a poor job, and (full circle) it is his fault we are under performing in March.
I enjoy your analysis but I think this is not a good conclusion and unfair to players, fans and coach.
Winning is very hard. Winning consistently is even harder. Peaking at the right time, with the right team, getting the right match ups, getting lucky and having guys healthy and elgible, etc. are a lot of variables and most of them are not due to coaching.
KU players, teams and our coach have actually done very well in the Self era, most years meeting or exceeding expectations. The tourney has been disappointing the last two years, and the "Killer Bs" have created a complex within the KU nation. The 2012 team was unbelievable and they way overachieved...and got lucky to make it to the finals. . .
The lack of our big man at the 5 during the last two tourneys has been far more significant and the source of our loses than the coaching. This year, we missed Cliff and last year we really missed Embiid. That's the way it goes in March and with a single elimination tourney.
My conclusion: Watching the elite teams this year, and watching KU this year (and last year), there is simply no way we were among the elite teams, and not final four talent. Maybe last year with Embiid, maybe...but certainly not this year, even with Cliff.
Respectfully, you write your post, concluding:
*Seeing Self's comments from last night really just make me angry. This team began the season as a Final Four team. This team was 21-4.
But that all changed, didn't it? We ended 6-5 and played embarrassingly bad against WSU. As Landen Lucas said, WSU just wanted it more.
I'm not sure there is any supposed injury that affects "want to." Though maybe a media member could ask Self. I'm sure he'd speculate on that. *
Respectively, this is in my opinion a cheap shot at the coach, the program and the players,
Having talent and having an eite team are not at all the same thing. How do they mature over the year as individuals and as a team? Duke's freshman actually came together as a unit and outperformed at just the right time. UK's talent was ridiculous (maybe they had the two best teams in the nation), The Badgers were senior laden with a great group and talented big men and they had been there last year...these were only the elite teams in the nation this year.
KU was just nowhere near that level. We could have got lucky, won another game or two, but probably got what we deserved at our level of performance and year end team talent (ability to perfom in a game, not rankings or potential).
I am of the opinion that WSU has had better teams than KU the last two years, and that our lose in the second round this year had more to do with them, than us. Great - game on! We accept the challenge and it is good for us and our program.
But throwing the coach under the bus for not reaching the final four this year...?
I enjoy the board and your posts and the others as well - next year, with one new elite talent big (and we will certainly get one), we will be better and ready to make a run.
Cheers!
RCJH