@JayHawkFanToo
The question is do you penalize the kid for the dealings of the guardian?
Likely, yes. The NCAA has usually penalized the kid in the end. The Cam Newton rule no longer applies. Look no further then Cliff Alexander as well. In broad terms yes I think Silvio could lose his eligibility if the paper trail is proven to lead to his guardian.
However I have the opinion the middle man Corey Dawkins kept the cash he was supposed to distribute. There hasn't been any evidence presented showing a paper trail leading back to anyone. I'll await to see whether that is true or not.
More importantly, do you penalize KU who apparently did not know anything about it?
It would be hard to see that happening without the NCAA having evidence to support the school/ coaches helping facilitate this whole situation. The Billy Preston situation helps KU actually, they found an issue and reported it. That shows a school willing to follow the rules. KU can use other players over the years as well showing a pattern of consistency following compliance. It's certainly not a lack of oversight issue. KU will have a strong case to support itself if the NCAA tried to give them some sort of violation(s).