I've also been following this ESPN poll, and I'm always interested to see who is placed where. So let me throw my hat into this debate.
However, I'm not going to argue the validity or justification of placing Self 6th, Marshall 8th, or Hoiberg 15th because the idea of ranking coaches based on this stringent criteria seems incredibly flawed to me. What I mean by that is, what is the difference between Greg Marshall and Shaka Smart? Pretty much nothing. Yet one of them is ranked in the top ten and the other at 13th. If Wichita St. went out and lost ten games with their garbage schedule and missed the tournament, would it surprise you? It wouldn't surprise me. However, I would be surprised if VCU missed the tournament, but even then, VCU has what, two tournament wins since going to the Final Four? Is that top 15 caliber material? Debatable. The name of the game is consistency. That word is synonymous with Bill Self.
My main point here is to pose the question: "who would you want running your program right now." Let's pretend anyone is available and your school needs a coach. THAT is probably the best criteria for ranking current coaches.
SO! Let's begin...
If Self is sixth, the other five will undoubtedly be Calipari, Coach K, Billy Donovan, Tom Izzo, and Rick Pitino.
Coach K is 70 years old. Automatic dismissal. I would want no part of him. I'm not saying he's not a great coach. I'm saying he's old. Self could coach for another 20 years at KU and surpass Coach K in wins and it would not surprise me. Hell, I'm halfway expecting it. I also can't stand the floor slapping crap on the sidelines. Jumping up and down like an angry chimp. I pass on K. Next!
Let me preface this by saying, I like Calipari. I think he's a better coach than a lot of people give hime credit for. That being said, Calipari is obviously a scumbag. The baggage that he carries works perfectly for UK and their black eye history. Calipari's approach to coaching is...let's call it unique, that you almost forget that Calipari is affiliated with an academic institution (although I do truly love listening to Kentucky fans laud the Jordan Junemans of their program for graduating from college as if it's some amazing feat). Calipari has been extremely successful at UK, and I find myself envying some of their success, but the problem is that absolutely, under no circumstances would I want an immoral man like that representing my alma mater. I cannot imagine the mortification I would feel for having to vacate Final Fours, or god forbid a national championship due to impropriety. Think of the stories you hear about Self in and around Lawrence...helping people push their cars out of the snow, going to the festivals downtown during the summer, taking pictures with anyone who asks. Self, in my opinion, is hands down the classiest coach in college basketball. THAT separates Self by a mile from Calipari.
That leaves us with Pitino, Izzo, and Donovan. I don't really have anything against these three. But I'll begin by saying Pitino and Izzo are in their early sixties, and although that's not that big of a deal, 50 is simply younger than 60.
Billy Donovan is certainly an enticing candidate. But again, consistency is the name of the game. Following back to back titles, Florida missed the tournament two years in a row, then lost to BYU in the first round on their first trip back....we would be calling for his head...
So I'll turn my opinion over to all of you. But I'll end by saying this... The simple question you have to ask yourself as a KU fan is...would you take any of these coaches over Self? To me,...no chance in hell.
RCJH