@Texas-Hawk-10 The differences between T-Rob and Dave are pretty stark. T-Rob was always known as a really bouncy, high motor athlete and that didn't change once he put on good weight at KU. Dave is athletically challenged. Almost every scout has commented he's an absolute liability defending away from the basket, where Robinson was not. Even when he gets his body right, he still won't be even an average athlete for the 4 spot. He's much, much better in the paint. We won't be able to switch much of anything with both he and Doke out there. The one thing he would be able to do is make the entry pass in the high low. And that's it. That's all he's got as a 4 man.
I don't buy the 2012 parallel for a few reasons. First is Withey was much more mobile than Doke, and could knock down the occasional midrange jumper if need be. Doke can't hit anything from outside the paint. T-Rob was also a fierce rebounder where Withey wasn't. McCormack and Withey actually had similar percentages in 18-19 and 11-12. If anything, McCormack is more like Withey than T-Rob. Had some touch for a center, not a great rebounder, but Dave isn't really a shot blocker, he was about the same as Dedric last year in block %. If anyone on the squad this year should look at Thomas's tape and try to emulate him, it's Silvio. Both have similar builds and skillsets. Thomas and Dave are really far apart. I think Dave's ceiling is a pretty skilled but athletically limited 5 with a really good motor. Nothing like Thomas. Silvio on the other hand has an elite motor and rebounding skills to go along with very good athleticism and not a lot of skill on offense. At least not that we've seen yet, but he did have a reputation of having a developing offensive skillset at IMG.
I think Wilson is the better option as the backup 4. He's obviously much more skilled offensively than McCormack, is an above average athlete for a 4, and still has the size to not get worked by a lot of 4's. And he can space the floor to allow Dotson and Garrett to drive. It would be breaking tendency for Self to cut his big rotation to 3 if he has the bodies to play 4. I can see some Perry Ellis in Wilson's game, which Bill loves.