@CRH107
You do have to innovate, but you have to innovate in the direction that things are moving. Right now, things are moving away from post ups and power basketball, to more of a drive and kick, four or five out offensive set.
You have to be able to defend those types of sets, because every midmajor will be running that type of set in the next few years - it's easier to find good guards than it is to find skilled big men. There are probably 15 guys in the KC area that are 6-5 or smaller that will play D1 somewhere. Any program can get most of those players. If you can't guard guys one on one when they put the ball on the floor, you will be surrendering open threes. Do that against a good shooting team and, well, we saw how a defense can get shredded in short order on Saturday night.
You can have whatever offensive gameplan you want, but if every other team is spreading the floor and shooting the three, you had better be able to at least defend that, regardless of what you do on the other end.
@BShark
I do think Self and staff can get Garrett's shot corrected. My major worry is that, although his shot isn't significantly mechanically broken (like Doke's FT stroke), the fact that it is reasonably sound and yet he is a legitimately bad shooter is a concern. For instance, Josh Jackson's shot had some mechanical flaws, but he was a better shooter than Garrett. When your mechanics are good, but your shot is bad, it's like being a pitcher with good mechanics that still can't throw strikes. If you can't fix the problem by fixing the mechanics, you have to just hope the person gets better. That's a tough bet. Garrett is a good athlete, and good athletes tend to be able to adjust, but this summer is crucial in his development.
Depth is developed over time. Part of that is that you have to play guys in situations that help them develop. I have beaten this drum for a while now, but Self cuts his rotation down too early in the season. That prevents you from developing depth. Guys have to play. Sam Cunliffe didn't play this year. Could he have been our ace in the hole if we needed to go small in a tournament game against a hot shooting, perimeter oriented team? KU was thin this year, but by the end of the season, our roster still had 9 legitimate D1 major conference players on it - Graham, Vick, Svi, Newman, Doke, De Sousa, Lightfoot, Garrett and Cunliffe. Yet in the last couple games of the season, Lightfoot didn't play, and Cunliffe basically never played all year.
If you want depth, in February when you're playing TCU, you have to give Cunliffe 10-12 minutes. You have to make sure De Sousa is playing 10 minutes a game. Same for Lightfoot. Garrett has to get minutes on the floor where he has to run the offense without Devonte. Sometimes Malik should have to initiate the offense with Svi and Cunliffe on the wings. Vick should have been doing that as well.
You can't develop depth if you only have guys in specific roles and never challenge them to handle other responsibilities for a few minutes a game.
DiVincenzo came off the bench for Nova basically all year. And yet, do you know how many games he scored 20+? Five. He even went for 30 once. So DiVincenzo going off in the title game was a surprise to the rest of the nation, but not if you were a Villanova fan. He had five games where he hit five or more threes. If you watched Villanova all year, you knew DiVincenzo could get hot and carry the night offensively. He did it a few times this year. That's how you develop depth. He had a role that he could excel in, but he was also put in a position where if he got hot, he could explode.
Why did Brannen Greene never do that at KU?
Why didn't Svi have a game or two like that every season prior to this year?
Andrew White? Cheick Diallo? Guys with a lot of potential that did more sitting and watching than anything else while at KU.
Where was Elijah Johnson in 2011? He played 5 minutes against VCU while Morningstar and Reed went a combined 2-16 from the field.
Self has always tightened his rotation when he gets into tough games, which means if his main guys are struggling, his team is doomed. That's what happened against Oregon - Vick played 27 minutes off the bench. Coleby played four. That was it for bench play.
But that's not a March problem. That's a February problem. You shouldn't be playing a guy 40 minutes, because you might not be able to ride him for 40 minutes in the tournament. These are the lessons March continues to teach. Next January we will find out what we learned.