@benshawks08 said in Racial Truths and Untruths and the Search for Justice while Doing Justice (previously titled To Infinity and Beyond):
@Texas-Hawk-10 So how much time is enough time for Black people to live in fear of the police? How long should they shoulder a disproportionate weight of bad policies that negatively impact the community?
I too have worked at a school under bad leadership and all seen good leadership but your post about your situation shows how far we all still have to go. If you are trying to get somewhere, do you take 4 small steps and then measure how far you are from your goal now?
It hurts me to see your willingness to classify a neighborhood in need as “gunspoint” and then resent them “coming to [your] school.”
And to address the ACLU tweet, you agree education has been long ignored and underfunded by both parties. Where do you think that funding has gone? What is one group both democratic and republican mayors and council groups continually add funding for? Hmm... Of only such a group existed.
So how much time is enough time for Black people to live in fear of the police? How long should they shoulder a disproportionate weight of bad policies that negatively impact the community?
Not the same question that I addressed. The change itself needed to happen much more recently than 2 years ago, but since there's no time machine to go back and address that issue, you have to start addressing them today. Minneapolis City Council's own statement suggests those changes didn't begin until 2 years ago when new policies and procedures were put into place. 2 years is nowhere near enough time to determine if those changes have had any meaningful positive effect. Instead, the city council decided to nuke everything and did so without a plan moving forward. That's bad leadership.
I too have worked at a school under bad leadership and all seen good leadership but your post about your situation shows how far we all still have to go. If you are trying to get somewhere, do you take 4 small steps and then measure how far you are from your goal now?
Yes, you take those small steps forward, evaluate what's working and what still needs to be improved on and keep moving forward. You don't backtrack just because you don't go from a standstill to full on spring immediately.
It hurts me to see your willingness to classify a neighborhood in need as “gunspoint” and then resent them “coming to [your] school.”
I don't resent those kids being zoned to my school. They were zoned to our school despite 3 other schools in the district being closer to that neighborhood because we were one of the top performer schools in the district and they were their previous school was the lowest performing. My issue was with the principal who end up being completely unprepared for that change in demographics and didn't do her homework and then didn't give any plans the leadership team at my school came up with enough time to work.
And to address the ACLU tweet, you agree education has been long ignored and underfunded by both parties. Where do you think that funding has gone? What is one group both democratic and republican mayors and council groups continually add funding for? Hmm... Of only such a group existed.
Considering that funding for education and police come from two different levels of government, that fact kind of ruins the story you're trying to create. School districts are funded at the state level while police departments are typically funded at the local level of government. The decrease in funding of public education isn't going where you're trying to imply it's going.
Properly fixing these systemic issues will never happen as quickly as anybody wants them to happen. That's the first thing people need to realize. Second thing is that these issues weren't created overnight and therefore will not be solved overnight either. You don't fix 350 years of legalized racism in 50 years. This issue is a marathon, not a sprint. Leaders from different groups with differing ideas need to come together to have discussions about applicable solutions that are achievable. The reason you have to have representatives from all sides involved because it gives ownership to all parties involved and gives them incentive to make these changes happen.
What's happening in Minneapolis and other places that are calling to defund police is that cry is pretty much only coming from one side, the far left. Even most moderates on the left are against this idea of defunding police departments. All that's going to come from what the Minneapolis City Council is doing is resentment and resistance from the right and moderate left because the city council is giving them little reason to want to see a new plan succeed because they no input into the new ideas.
They're doing exactly to the right what has been happening to the black community for generations and that's silencing their voices. Most BLM supporters aren't anti-white, they just want their voices heard and respected as well along with white people. We know what silencing an influential groups voice does because we're seeing it right now with these protests and riots and the left trying to silence the voice of the right isn't going to end well for anyone in Minneapolis.